Summary of studies used in the comparative assessments - Runoff Prediction in Ungauged Basins: Synthesis across Processes, Places and Scales - page 398

Table A7.1. (cont.)

Climate zone
(Köppen
classes)

No. of
catchments

Period/No.
of years

Regionalisa-
tion method

Predicted
variable

Used
in L1

Used
in L2

Area (km 2 )

Study Region P A (mm/yr) Error Error measure

q (1 … 365) Arora et al.

( 2005 )

India (western
Himalaya)

Arid (BSh,
Cwa, Cwb)

1566 -
22 400

9/2 14 to 23 yrs IM 1.50 meanANE X

Arora et al.
( 2005 )

India (western
Himalaya)

Arid (BSh,
Cwa, Cwb)

1566 -
22 400

9/2 14 to 23 yrs R q i 0.40 meanANE X

Arora et al.
( 2005 )

India (western
Himalaya)

Arid (BSh,
Cwa, Cwb)

1566 -
22 400

9/2 14 to 23 yrs R q i 0.40 meanANE X

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 32 - 3082 824 - 1505 51 IM q i 0.71 percNSlw75 X

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 20 - 3070 824 - 1505 51 R q i 0.69 percNSlw75 X

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 20 - 3070 824 - 1505 51 IM q i 0.78 percNSlw75 X

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 20 - 3070 824 - 1505 51 SR q i 0.46 percNSlw75 X

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 20 - 3070 824 - 1505 51 SR q i 0.34 percNSlw75 X

20 - 3070 824 - 1505

Castellarin et al.
( 2004a )

North-central
Italy

Humid (Cfa) 51 SR q i 0.22 percNSlw75 X

Yu et al.( 2002 ) Taiwan Humid (Cfa) 42 - 683 1833 - 3376 15 R q i 1.00 percANElw100 X

Yu et al.( 2002 ) Taiwan Humid (Cfa) 42 - 683 1833 - 3376 15 R q i 0.87 percANElw100 X

Holmes et al.
( 2002 )

United
Kingdon

Humid (Cfb) 523/130 R q 95 0.64 median

RRMSE

Yu and Yang
( 1996 )

Taiwan Humid (Cfa) 2700 34 IM Area

under
the FDC

0.30 NAE

R: regression method
IM: index method
SR: short records method
percNSElw75: percentage of sites with NSE lower than 0.75
medianANE: mean absolute normalised error (in the middle of the FDC)
meanRRMSE: mean relative root mean square error
percANElw100: percentage of sites with median ANE lower than 100%
NAreaE: normalised area error
q i : selection of runoff quantiles from the FDC
q (1 … 365) : all values from the FDC
No. of catchments (calibration/validation)