Summary of studies used in the comparative assessments - Runoff Prediction in Ungauged Basins: Synthesis across Processes, Places and Scales - page 394

Table A6.1. (cont.)

Climate zone
(Köppen
classes)

P A (mm/
yr)

Elevation
(m a.s.l.)

q A (mm/
yr)

No. of
catchments

Period/No.
of years

Regionalisa-
tion method

Predicted
variable

Performance
(NSE, R 2 )

Error
measure

Used in
L1

Area (km 2 )

Study Region Error Used in L2

q m (max)

Markovic and
Koch ( 2006 )

Germany (Elbe
River)

Humid (Cfb,
Dfb)

5.68 - 103 8/2 1953 - 1960/

1960 -
2000

G 0.98 - 0.99 6.4 - 12.7 RRMSE

Dudley ( 2004 ) USA (Maine) Cold (Dfb) 25 - 3672 960 - 1217 26 min 10 yrs R q m 11.1 - 30.2 RRMSE

Hess ( 2002 ) USA (Nevada) Cold (Dfb,

BSk)

0.93 - 137 429 - 640 2560 - 3109 6 R q m 0.21 - 0.87

Baldwin et al.
( 2002 )

USA (Utah) Arid (BSk,

Dfb, Dfa)

181 R q m 0.20 - 1.90 CV NE

Schreider et al.
( 2002 )

Northern
Thailand

Tropical (Am) 1/2 PB q m 0.13 - 0.18 NBIAS

Hortness and
Berenbrock
( 2001 )

USA (Idaho) Arid (BSk,

Dsb)

7.77 - 34 705 208 - 1641 732 - 2896 200 IM q m,80 ,

q m,50 ,
q m,20

- 15.3 - 18.1 NBIAS

Sauquet et al.
( 2000 )

South-east
France

Arid (Csb,
Csa)

50 - 96 500 201/11 G q m /q A 0.70 - 0.98 X

Peel et al.
( 2000 )

Australia Humid (Cwa,

Cfa, Cfb,
Csa)

51 - 1980 297 - 2445 3 - 2095 331 PB q m

Abdulla and
Lettenmaier
( 1997 )

USA (Arkansas) Humid (Cfa) 285 - 5278 53 - 2344 40/6 PB q d 0.05 - 0.80 0.37 - 0.82 RRMSE

Raman et al.
( 1995 )

India (Tamil
Nadu)

Humid (Cwb,
Cwa, Aw)

74.7 700 1 7/1 R q m - 0.24 - 0.32 NE

Vandewiele and
Elias ( 1995 )

Belgium Humid (Cfb) 19 - 1597 75 4 to 35 yrs PB q m 3.43 - 4.76 RMSE

(mm)

Ibrahim and
Cordery
( 1995 )

Australia (New
South Wales)

Arid (BSh,
BWh, BSk)

190 - 1870 620 - 2400 18/8 15 to 50 yrs PB q m 0.62 - 0.89 X

Rankl et al.
( 1994 )

USA (Wyoming) Arid (BWk,
BSk)

21 R q m 0.74 - 0.93 0.37 - 0.83 NE

Rankl et al.
( 1994 )

USA (Wyoming) Arid (BWk,
BSk)

21 R q m 0.65 - 0.95 0.34 - 1.00 NE

Rankl et al.
( 1994 )

USA (Wyoming) Arid (BWk,
BSk)

21 R q m 0.27 - 1.51 NE

Gan et al.
( 1991 )

Australia (south-
east Victoria)

Humid (Cfb) 0.06 - 246 700 - 1400 59/12 5 to 25 yrs R(A, P A ,

P month )

q m - 0.47 - 0.16 NBIAS

Parrett and
Johnson
( 1989 )

USA (Montana) Arid (BSk,
Dfb)

17 R q m 0.35 - 1.57 NE