Summary of studies used in the comparative assessments - Runoff Prediction in Ungauged Basins: Synthesis across Processes, Places and Scales - page 393

Table A6.1. Summary of studies used in the comparative assessment of seasonal runoff estimation

Climate zone
(Köppen
classes)

P A (mm/
yr)

Elevation
(m a.s.l.)

q A (mm/
yr)

No. of
catchments

Period/No.
of years

Regionalisa-
tion method

Predicted
variable

Performance
(NSE, R 2 )

Error
measure

Used in
L1

Area (km 2 )

Study Region Error Used in L2

Moore et al.
( 2012 )

Canada (British
Columbia)

Cold (Dfb,
Dsb, Dfc,
Cfb)

0.8 - 6760 226 min 10 yrs PB q m 0.92 X X

40 - 3310 117 - 4727

Bartolini et al.
( 2011 )

North-west Italy Cold (Dfb,
Cfa)

40 PB q m

Gitau and
Chaubey
( 2010 )

USA (Arkansas) Humid (Cfa) 1400 - 6600 7/3 PB q d 0.53 - 0.83

Gitau and
Chaubey
( 2010 )

USA (Arkansas) Humid (Cfa) 1400 - 6600 7/3 PB q d 0.4 - 0.75

Snelder et al.
( 2009 )

France Humid (Cfb,

Csb, Dfc)

3 - 109 000 606 - 2060 763 1976 - 2006 R q m 0.37 - 0.64 PMR

Sauquet et al.
( 2008 )

France Humid (Cfb,

Csb, Dfc)

11.5 - 109 930 100 - 1500 154 1981 - 2000 G q m 0.98 X X

Sauquet et al.
( 2008 )

France Humid (Cfb,

Csb, Dfc)

11.5 - 109 930 100 - 1500 65 1981 - 2000 G q m 0.94 X X

Kapangaziwiri
and Hughes
( 2008 )

South Africa,
Zimbabwe
and
Mozambique

Arid (BWk,
BSk, Aw,
Cwa)

6.5 - 1100 575 - 1637 71 PB q m 0.60 - 0.85 X

Cutore et al.
( 2007 )

Italy (Sicily) Arid (Csa) 19 - 1832 524 - 1479 9 15 to 38 yrs PB q m 0.59 X

Cutore et al.
( 2007 )

Italy (Sicily) Arid (Csa) 19 - 1832 524 - 1479 9 15 to 38 yrs PB q m 0.66 X

Cutore et al.
( 2007 )

Italy (Sicily) Arid (Csa) 19 - 1832 524 - 1479 9 15 to 38 yrs PB q m 0.69 X

Sanborn and
Bledsoe
( 2006 )

USA (Colorado,
Washington,
Oregon)

Cold (Dsc,
Cfb)

4 - 19 632 335 - 4500 0 - 3180 62 min 20 yrs R q m 0.963 - 0.985 X

Sanborn and
Bledsoe
( 2006 )

USA (Colorado,
Washington,
Oregon)

Humid (Cfb) 4 - 19 632 335 - 4500 0 - 3180 37 min 20 yrs R q m 0.91 - 0.98 X

Sanborn and
Bledsoe
( 2006 )

USA (Colorado,
Washington,
Oregon)

Humid (Cfb,
Dsc)

4 - 19 632 335 - 4500 0 - 3180 35 min 20 yrs R q m 0.84 - 0.93 X

Sanborn and
Bledsoe
( 2006 )

USA (Colorado,
Washington,
Oregon)

Arid (BSk,
Dsc)

4 - 19 632 335 - 4500 0 - 3180 28 min 20 yrs R q m 0.68 - 0.91 X