Map Drawing Competition for Children in Indonesia - Maps for the Future Children Education and Internet - page 263

Fig. 21.7 Elimination process during judgment of national competition in 2009
The juries individually nominated 2 drawings for each group, totaling 18 drawings.
A drawing that was nominated by most juries automatically became an overall
winner. The juries would then discuss to select the drawings nominated by only one
jury until we obtained five overall winners. Each jury would then give a score of
1-100 to the rest of 40 finalists, considering map contents, theme suitability and
creativity. The score was necessary in case winning candidates failed verification
process.
21.2.3.2 Local Competitions
Local competitions were usually held from 9 AM to 12 PM in a hall provided by the
local hosts. The children, unaccompanied by their family members, sat on the floor
according to their ID numbers. After all participants sat in the place assigned to
them, organizing committee distributed drawing papers to be used. The judgment
process begun soon after the organizing committee collected all the drawings.
Board of juries for local competition usually comprised of three persons: at least
one of them came from BAKOSURTANAL and at least one jury taken from a local
paint artist who had experience as a jury for children's drawing competitions.
Similar to the judgment process of national competitions, here all the juries together
determined the best 15 drawings from every group, to get the total of 45 finalists.
The winners were determined by the total scores given by all juries.
During the scoring stage, every jury individually evaluated each drawing based
on certain criteria, which are: theme suitability, map contents, creativity, color
composition, and drawing technique. Each component of the criteria was given a
weigh factor as follow:
• Theme suitability: 0.30,
• Map contents: 0.20,
• Creativity: 0.20,
• Color composition: 0.15,
• Drawing technique: 0.15.