Information Technology Reference
In-Depth Information
In either case you should:
Provide good references with which the authors should be familiar.
Ask yourself whether your comments are fair, specific, and polite.
Be honest about your limitations as a referee of that paper.
Check your review as carefully as you would check one of your own papers prior
to submission.
Present your arguments in reasonable detail; your writing and presentation may not
be at the same standard as in a paper, but the rigour of argument should be similar.
Remember that the editor will tend to trust your judgement and views ahead of that
of the author. Do not abuse that trust.
