THE THEORY OF COGNITIVE FIT - Human-Computer Interaction and Management Information Systems: Foundations - page 143

Table 8.5

Characteristics of Cognitive Fit Studies on Judgments in the Accounting Domain

Dependent Variables

Independent Variables Accuracy Time/Efficiency

PR (matched

Study Task Type with task type) Expected Actual Expected Actual

Umanath Holistic Holistic G F G F F G F G

and (Chernoff faces)

Vessey Spatial (G) F T F T F T F T (marginal)

(1994) (Symbolic) TT G T G T

Tuttle and Holistic Spatial (G) For holistic strategy: For holistic strategy: For holistic strategy: For holistic strategy:

Kershaw Symbolic (T) Jmt consistency: G T Jmt consistency: G T Jmt time: G T Jmt time: G T

(1998) (Note: the Jmt model quality: G T Jmt model quality: G T

researchers:
• Manipulated

For analytical strategy: For analytical strategy: For analytical strategy: For analytical strategy:

strategy and

Jmt consistency: T G Jmt consistency: T G Jmt time: T G Jmt time: T G

• Ignored

Jmt model quality: T G Jmt model quality: T G

task type)

Note : Results in underlined type are not significant; results in bold type contradict expectations.