Agriculture Reference
In-Depth Information
Table 6.3.
Some results of feeding studies with feed from various GM plants with different traits of the fi rst generation in food-producing animals (in comparison
with isogenic counterparts and mostly with commercial varieties).
Animal species/
category (animals
per treatment)
Duration (days) or
living span (kg)
Portion in diet (%
or kg)
GM plant/trait
Parameters
Main results
References
Maize
Insect protected (Bt maize);
silage
Dairy cattle (12)
91 days
70%
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition
No signifi cant infl uence on
milk yield and composition
Barriere
et al
., 2001
Insect protected (Bt 11 maize);
silage/grain
Dairy cattle (16)
4
21 days
40/28% of DM;
silage/grain
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition, rumen
fermentation
No signifi cant effects on
intake, yield and rumen
fermentation
Folmer
et al
., 2002
Glyphosate-tolerant or insect-
protected (European corn
borer) maize; silage and
grain (3 trials)
Dairy cattle (6/8/8)
63/84/84 days
42-60% silage;
20-34% grain
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition, ruminal
degradability
No signifi cant differences in all
measured parameters
Donkin
et al
., 2003
Glyphosate-tolerant (RR) and
rootworm-resistant maize
(Bt); grain, silage
Dairy cattle; 2
studies; 2
4
4
Latin square
28/21 days
40/23% silage/
grain (1);
26.7% grain (2)
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition
No effect on milk yield and
composition
Grant
et al
., 2003
Glyphosate tolerant; silage and
grain (RR-NK603 maize)
Dairy cattle; 4
4
Latin square (8)
56 days
30% silage;
27.3% grain
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition
No signifi cant effect on milk
yield and milk composition
Ipharraguerre
et al
.,
2003
Insect protected (Bt), herbicide
tolerant; silage
Dairy cattle (8)
28 days
45%
Milk yield, composition,
tDNA, Cry1Ab
No infl uence on composition
of silage and milk, milk
yield, no tDNA and Cry1Ab
in milk
Calsamiglia
et al
.,
2007
Insect protected (Bt); silage,
grain
Dairy cattle (15)
765 days
63% roughage,
41%
concentrate
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition, tDNA,
Cry1AB, metabolic
parameters
No signifi cant infl uence on
measured data
Guertler
et al
., 2009;
Spiekers
et al
.,
2009; Steinke
et al
.,
2010
Insect-protected (rootworm)
and herbicide (glufosinate)-
tolerant maize
Dairy cattle (15;
switchback
design)
28 days
23% grain; 21%
silage
Feed intake, milk yield,
composition
No signifi cant infl uence of GM
feed on all parameters
Brouk
et al
., 2011