Summary of studies used in the comparative assessments - Runoff Prediction in Ungauged Basins: Synthesis across Processes, Places and Scales - page 402

Table A8.1. (cont.)

Climate zone
(Köppen
classes)

Area
(km 2 )

P A (mm/
yr)

Elevation
(m a.s.l.)

No. of
catchments

Regional
method

Predicted
variable

Performance
(R 2 )

Error
(RRMSE)

Used
in L1

Used
in L2 Study Region

Rees et al.
( 2002 )

Himalayas,
Nepal and
India

Humid (Cwb,
Cwa)

40 GR q 95 /q A 0.45 X

Rees et al.
( 2002 )

Himalayas,
Nepal and
India

Humid (Cwb,
Cwa)

40 GR q 95 /q A 0.53 X

Young et al.
( 2000a , b )

UK Humid (Cfb) IM q 95 /q A 1.33 (f.s.

e.)

Young et al.
( 2000a , b )

UK Humid (Cfb) RR q 95 /q A 1.71 (f.s.

e.)

Aschwanden and
Kan ( 1999 )

Switzerland Cold (ET, Dfb,

ETH, Dfc)

143 GR q 95 0.51 0.48 X

Aschwanden and
Kan ( 1999 )

Switzerland Cold (ET, Dfb,

ETH, Dfc)

143 RR q 95 0.59 - 0.84 0.34 X

Smakhtin ( 1997 ) South Africa Arid (BWk,

BSk)

PB q x , MAM d

Demuth and
Hagemann
( 1994 )

Germany
(Baden-
Württemberg)

Humid (Cfb) 54 GR BFI 0.86 0.21 X

Demuth ( 1993 ) Germany

(Baden-
Württemberg)

Humid (Cfb) 54 GR BFI 0.81 0.25 X

Demuth ( 1993 ) Germany

(Baden-
Württemberg)

Humid (Cfb) 54 GR BFI 0.84 0.23 X

Gustard et al.
( 1992 )

UK Humid (Cfb) GR MAM d /Q A

Gustard et al.
( 1992 )

UK Humid (Cfb) RR MAM d /Q A

Nathan and
McMahon
( 1990 , 1992 )

Australia (New
South Wales,
Victoria)

Arid (BSk,
BWh BSh,
Cfb, Cfa)

184 RR BFI 0.75 - 0.83 0.08 X