Summary of studies used in the comparative assessments - Runoff Prediction in Ungauged Basins: Synthesis across Processes, Places and Scales - page 390

Table A5.1. (cont.)

Error
(RMSE in
mm/yr)

Climate zone
(Köppen classes)

P A (mm/
yr)

Elevation
(m a.s.l.)

q A (mm/
yr)

No. of
catchments

Period/No.
of years

Regionalisation
method

Predicted
variable

Performance
(r 2 )

Used in
L1

Area (km 2 )

Study Region

Gou et al.( 2007 ) China (Yellow

River)

Humid (Cwa,
Cfa)

680 000 300 - 500 1 1956 -

2001

PX Q A 0.25 - 0.41

(R 2 )

X

Woodhouse and Lucas
( 2006 )

USA (Upper
Colorado
River)

Cold (Dfb) 4 1906 - 95 PX Q A 0.64 - 0.81

(R 2 )

X

Sauquet ( 2006 ) France Humid (Cfb, Dfc,

Csa, Csb)

11 111 570 300 - 2500 70 - 1860 898/90 1981 -

2000

SP q A 0.6 - 0.97 35 - 178 X

Bren et al.( 2006 ) Southern

Australia (Pine
Creek)

Humid (Cfa, Cfb) 3.2 787 2 1988 -

2000

R(P A , plant
age)

q A 95

Beriault and Sauchyn
( 2006 )

Canada
(Churchill
River)

Cold (Dfb, Dfc) 45 000 -

215 000

3 25 to 66

yrs

PX Q A 0.40 - 0.53

(R 2 adj)

X

Carson and Munroe ( 2005 ) USA (Utah) Arid (Bsk) 262 675 - 925 1 1915 - 71 PX Q A 0.63 - 0.70

(R 2 adj)

X

Case and MacDonald
( 2003 )

Canada
(Saskatchewan
River)

Cold (Dfb, Dfc) 3 1912 - 98 PX Q A 0.34 - 0.59

(R 2 adj)

X

0.40 - 0.95 Sankarasubramanian and

Vogel ( 2002 )

Continental USA Global (Cfa, Dfa,
Dfb, Bsk, Bsw,
Csa, Csb, Dfc)

1337 min 10

yrs

PB q A X

Parajka ( 2001 ) Slovakia Cold (Dfb, Dfc,

E)

30 - 4800 140 - 1200 60/60 1951 - 80 IM q A 0.91 - 0.95 77 - 289 X

Parajka ( 2001 ) Slovakia Cold (Dfb, Dfc,

E)

30 - 4800 140 - 1200 60/60 1951 - 80 SP q A 0.96 - 0.99 100 - 244 X

Parajka ( 2001 ) Slovakia Cold (Dfb, Dfc,

E)

30 - 4800 140 - 1200 60/60 1951 - 80 R(P A , T A ) q A 0.69 - 0.95 74 - 323 X

3.5 - 3·10 7

Vogel and
Sankarasubramanian
( 2000 )

Continental USA Global (Cfa, Dfa,
Dfb, Bsk, Bsw,
Csa, Csb, Dfc)

1433 6 to 115

yrs

R(log A) Q A 0.28 - 0.99 X

Sauquet et al.( 2000a ) France (Saône

River)

Humid (Cfb) 54 - 11 700 313 - 1414 20 1960 - 97 SP q A 0.90

− 23 (bias
in
mm)

X

Wolock and McCabe
( 1999 )

Continental USA Global (Cfa, Dfa,
Dfb, Bsk, Bsw,
Csa, Csb, Dfc)

23 - 2530 344 regions
(not
catchments)

1951 - 80 PB q A 0.64 - 0.93 X