Decision Support Tool for Design and Reliability Assessment of Water Distribution Networks - Pattern Recognition for Reliability Assessment of Water Distribution Networks - page 253

Table 9.6 Results of network filtering for NfullC4, unrestricted connectivity

Network filtering tool (Ver. 1.00 by N.Trifunovic)

Report file: g50t1FULLcpx4cf.xls

Total number of links in the template file (g50t1.inp): 130

Number of networks to be filtered: 100

No File name NoLinks Match Deficit PiDif1 PiDif2 Status Comment No File name NoLinks Match Deficit PiDif1 PiDif2 Status Comment

1 Input_001.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 51 Input_051.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

2 Input_002.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 52 Input_052.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

3 Input_003.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 53 Input_053.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

4 Input_004.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 54 Input_054.inp 76 74 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

5 Input_005.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 55 Input_055.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

6 Input_006.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 56 Input_056.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

7 Input_007.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 57 Input_057.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

8 Input_008.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 58 Input_058.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

9 Input_009.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 59 Input_059.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

10 Input_010.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 60 Input_060.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

11 Input_011.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 61 Input_061.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

12 Input_012.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 62 Input_062.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

13 Input_013.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 63 Input_063.inp 76 74 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem

14 Input_014.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 64 Input_064.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

15 Input_015.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 65 Input_065.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

16 Input_016.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 66 Input_066.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

17 Input_017.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 67 Input_067.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

18 Input_018.inp 76 74 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 68 Input_068.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

19 Input_019.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 69 Input_069.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

20 Input_020.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 70 Input_070.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

21 Input_021.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 71 Input_071.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

22 Input_022.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 72 Input_072.inp 77 75 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

23 Input_023.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 73 Input_073.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

24 Input_024.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 74 Input_074.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

25 Input_025.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 75 Input_075.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

26 Input_026.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 76 Input_076.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

27 Input_027.inp 76 74 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 77 Input_077.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

28 Input_028.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 78 Input_078.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

29 Input_029.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 79 Input_079.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

30 Input_030.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 80 Input_080.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

31 Input_031.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 81 Input_081.inp 77 76 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem

32 Input_032.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 82 Input_082.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

33 Input_033.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 83 Input_083.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

34 Input_034.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 84 Input_084.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

35 Input_035.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 85 Input_085.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

36 Input_036.inp 77 75 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem 86 Input_086.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

37 Input_037.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 87 Input_087.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

38 Input_038.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 88 Input_088.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

39 Input_039.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 89 Input_089.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

40 Input_040.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 90 Input_090.inp 77 75 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

41 Input_041.inp 74 73 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 91 Input_091.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

42 Input_042.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 92 Input_092.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

43 Input_043.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 93 Input_093.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

44 Input_044.inp 75 74 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 94 Input_094.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

45 Input_045.inp 76 75 1 49 Rejected! Match<Tem 95 Input_095.inp 75 73 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

46 Input_046.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 96 Input_096.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

47 Input_047.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 97 Input_097.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

48 Input_048.inp 75 73 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 98 Input_098.inp 76 74 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

49 Input_049.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 99 Input_099.inp 77 75 2 49 69 Rejected! Match<Tem

50 Input_050.inp 74 72 2 49 68 Rejected! Match<Tem 100 Input_100.inp 76 74 2 49 70 Rejected! Match<Tem

Filtered: 100 Rejected: 100

Table 9.7 Results of network filtering for five batches of 1000 nets

Batch
Code

Time (sec) Pipe range Avg. Net match MisM range Avg. miss

R55-75 (U) 1597 58-75 70.85 3 0-10 5.66

NfullC2(4) 1662 50-56 52.25 477 0-1 0.52

NfullC4(U) 1216 74-79 75.59 0 1-2 1.75

N55-75C2(4) 1695 55-57 55.22 375 0-1 0.63

N55-75C4(U) 1211 74-75 74.71 0 1-2 1.70