Environmental Engineering Reference
In-Depth Information
Table 3.5 Estimated average cost function for UV-Based AOP in 2008 CDN dollars
Disinfection Technology
Average Cost function
Predicted cost per cubic meter in
Can $ based on plant with daily
capacity in m
3
100 m
3
200 m
3
500 m
3
y = 0.7576x
−
0.3394
UV-Based AOP
0.21
0.18
0.14
Details of the NLLS estimate are shown in Appendix
B
. We included an
additional cost for
filtration for surface waters for this AOP of 5 cents per cubic
meter in the predicted costs in Table
3.5
. We estimate that Class 5 treatment can
cost $0.21 per cubic meter for a small plant with a daily capacity of 100 m
3
. Note
that our statistical modeling estimation, based on data supplied by manufacturers,
indicates that this Advanced Oxidation Process is cheaper than ozonation and will
remove a number of micro-pollutants (see description in Table
3.3
). When plant-
speci
c costs are taken into account, our information indicates that a representative
plant at a scale of 3800 cubic meters per day would cost around $0.45 per cubic
meter (in 2008 Canadian dollars).
7
We hasten to add that our cost estimation models yield what we can call
“
rst
approximation costs
”
and what is the most appropriate technology will depend on
site-speci
c (i.e. the particular location) factors. It is best left to the consulting
engineers to do a thorough cost estimation for speci
c sites.
3.5 Reverse Osmosis and Nano
ltration (Class 6)
Reverse Osmosis and Nano Filtration, which can also remove salinity, is classi
ed
as Class 6. Dore (
2005
) shows that for a
flow rate of 5,000 cubic meters per day,
the cost of producing drinking water was US $0.50 per cubic meter per day in 2005.
In a later article, Fritzmann et al. (
2007
) put the costs at actual desalination plants to
be between US$0.48 and $0.53 cents. Finally, in a comprehensive review of the
cost of desalination literature, Karagiannis and Soldatos (
2008
) show that for
capacities between 500 and 1,000 m
3
, RO costs range from US$0.75 cents to
$3.93 per m
3
per day. For capacities less than 1000 m
3
, they
nd that the costs
range from US $2.22 to as much as $19 per m
3
per day. All authors mentioned here
recognize the importance of economies of scale in the determination of unit costs.
To some extent, RO with granular activated carbon is a
tech-
nology, mainly suitable for large systems, and so RO and other such technologies
We can also compare the above cost data with the costs of a Point-of-use (POU)
Reverse osmosis system. POU costs range from 2.5 to 5 cents per liter or $25 to $50
“
state-of-the-art
”
7
Personal communication from Mr. Morris McCormick, Drinking water treatment plant, City of
Cornwall, Ontario.
Search WWH ::
Custom Search