Semiotic Design and Evaluation Framework - Cross-Cultural Human-Computer Interaction and User Experience Design - page 44

• Barrel distortion: Optical lens correction vs. Perspective clone
• Clone objects in perspective: Vanishing point vs. Perspective clone tool
• Customize the UI: Keyboard shortcuts and menu customization vs. Config-
ure keyboard shortcuts
• Eliminate an object: Healing brush vs. Clone tool
• Reduce red eye: One-click red-eye tool vs. Red-eye removal
Note: we have not included in the “Top 5” list above the following functions:
• Colorize black and white: Shadow/highlight vs. Channel mixer
• Change resolution of file
• Move object to a layer
• Save image as PDF/PS
• Trim background
Following the above list, we are going to analyze each function by first transcribing
the step-by-step process involved. Then, we shall focus on the HE and SA for each one.
Because terminology differs considerably between the two products, in the transcript,
we used only one version to make it concise.